Author: cliveoconnell

THE MESSIAEN NEXUS

Elisabeth Sellars and Kenji Fujimura

Move Records MD 3369

Like many celebrated composers, Messiaen served as a nodal point, but not in establishing his own school, nor in being part of a substantial movement.  He stands out in the ranks of 20th century composers as a complete individual, even on a superficial level, for combining so many elements that other writers avoided or simply could not use.  The point of this CD is to indicate where Messiaen came from – although this retrospective glance is pretty frail – and the fruits of his pedagogic labours, which were legendary, in works by his students.

Elisabeth Sellars and Kenji Fujimura, colleagues in the Faculty of Music at Monash University, are long-time duo partners and this collection of seven works furthers their reputation as exemplary duo-artists.   As you’d expect, Messiaen is represented: first, by the solo piano Piece pour le tombeau de Paul Dukas of 1935, and, in the last track, by the Fantaisie for violin and piano, written in 1933 but not published until 2007.

But the disc begins with a violin/piano Sonata by George Benjamin, the British composer who studied with Messiaen and reputedly was the French master’s favourite pupil; mind you, Benjamin was very young at the time and the first movement of this work was finished at about the time that he began his studies with Messiaen..  Another pupil, Gyorgy Kurtag, is represented by Tre Pezzi from 1979 and some pieces from the solo violin collection Signs, Games and Messages, generally brief in length; the elements for this instrument’s version assembled from 1989 to 2004.  At the recording’s centre stands Anthemes for violin solo by Boulez, a late work from 1991 that was, typically, later revised to include electronics as part of the sound-mix.

Benjamin’s sonata, the most substantial work on this CD, has a unique vocabulary.  It begins with pointillist dollops of piano notes over which the violin stretches a long melodic line.  The pace is slow, hieratic, and you can hear Messiaenic trace-elements in the repetitions of both lines and the occasional suggestion of a mode or two in the keyboard writing.  In the movement’s central pages, where the ambience tends toward a Bartok brutality, the instrumental dialogue verges on the obsessive, especially in the piano’s sometimes clangorous writing.   In fact, the more you listen, the more teacher references you pick up, like the Quartet for the end of time tenor of the movement’s conclusion.

The quicker middle movement involves more under-the-lid work and a good deal of nervous ostinati, the whole heavy on effects; like his master, Benjamin is not concerned about unexpected referents that may occur to the listener, like the dance-hall suggestions that pop up, especially from some sinuous violin curvetting.  But the segment ends in a set of frenetic yet organized pages where the excitement level rises but you are aware of a mind in control of the ferment. The finale  is slow-paced, both more mellow than its opening counterpart and more dramatic in its gestures.   Again, you can find the influence of Messiaen in the slow-paced final peroration which, rather than ending in beatitude as the master would, finishes in a state of unresolved meditativeness.

Dukas, whose The Sorcerer’s Apprentice and Fanfare for the ballet La Peri are all that survive in the concert hall, taught Messiaen – as well as an honour roll of other European composers.   He was invited, like Ravel and Debussy, by the Societe Internationale de Musique in 1910 to write a work using Haydn’s name as inspiration – well, a jumping-off point; the Prelude elegiaque was the result, three somewhat desultory pages that begin and end in harmonic stacks, if suitably placid in character, with a more ornate middle moment.   If you want, you can find in the piece’s sustained and wide-ranging chords a precedent for something like the final movement of L’ascension – or not.   Fujimura’s reading is calm, the chords carefully splayed although the final bars fail to register fully on my equipment.

Kurtag’s Tre Pezzi are brief, making their respective statements without much by way of development.   Od und traurig lives up to its name, notable for deliberately off-kilter violin sustained notes that suggest depression and desolation; Vivo has both instruments moving more rapidly in a suggested march-rhythm, but the forward propulsion is interrupted by pauses and you hear few moments of full-bodied sound; Aus der Ferne sits for some of its length close to inaudibility, out-Weberning Webern with the violin playing simple diatonic sequences, the piano interpolating occasional punctuation marks as a  background.  Where this fits into the CD’s nexus musically speaking is hard to see.

Much the same could be said of the Boulez Anthemes, four pages packed with difficulties for any performer; just getting the improbably detailed expression markings correct presents Sellars with a huge task which she carries out with sense.  If the distinction between her piano and pianissimo delivery in bar 65 on alternate up and down bows is vague, who can blame her?   The work has a wealth of detail, superlatively organized and suited to the instrument’s potential.   But the time-changes, abrupt differentiations in modes of sound-production, flow-disrupting demi-semiquaver gruppetti, massively taxing quadruple stops – all combine to focus your attention on the instrumental timbre, rather than the intended sequence between initial and of verse  – as in the Tudor Lamentations settings – that prompted the composer.   A pity, as this is one of the few Boulez pieces I’m aware of that has any connection to religious inspiration and a less distracting environment might have revealed a sensibility that is masked with virtuosity in most of the composer’s greatest scores.  His teacher based the greater part of his oeuvre on his emphatically expressed faith although he didn’t write much that could be comfortably shaped to fit any liturgies, apart from those in his own head.

Messiaen’s tribute to Dukas may be an early work but it speaks the composer’s tongue eloquently, using one of his own modes of limited transposition and proceeding in a processional pace, albeit one with no allowance for regularity of step.   If anything, the work is triumphant in impact, without virtuosic demands except to get the fingers across those massive chord chains that resolve onto a dominant seventh; well, Messiaen says so although the key chord seems to me to be something else entirely.   Fujimura gives the piece plenty of space to make its celebratory statements with firm amplitude.

The four pieces from Signs, Games and Messages present few problems to Sellars.  The first, Doloroso, is a plaint that passes all too rapidly; Postcard to Anna Keller was written on the day of the dedicatee’s birth and is buoyant, optimistic and folksy in a strident fashion; Calmo-Sognando is an In memoriam for an old school-friend that expresses a masculine, mobile regret despite all the tapering away of its final phrase; the In nomine – all’ongherese begins with a stern one-line motive – and stays with it, the atmosphere growing more and more nationalistic as the short work proceeds.   In all, an intriguing bracket of works but the links to this CD’s nodal point seem tenuous.

Finally, Messiaen’s Fantaisie begins with a piano statement familiar to most organists: the opening recitative to the Alleluias sereins d’une ame qui desire le ciel, the second movement of L’ascension.  This angular proclamation recurs later in duo form with both players in unison, further on with a vitally contrasting piano support, and in a truncated form at the work’s final flourishes.   In between come interludes that are both sweet bordering on saccharine and drivingly active; it may be a young man’s work but it is already idiosyncratic and totally inimitable.

Which brings us back to the disc’s title.  It is probably the best term to describe the performers’ attempt; what they have contributed is a brief tour of voices that spring out of the Messiaen fulcrum.  Expecting them all to share a commonality of expression is to look for connections and links that are either not there or have been assuaged by individual development.

Mind you, the master might have been a wonder in the seminar room but he could also be a curmudgeon.  A one-time colleague, Anna King-Murdoch, accompanied Messiaen to the Dandenongs during one of his rare visits here; the composer was, as usual, wanting to transcribe some native bird song.  He’d heard of the lyrebird but never experienced its mimicking ability live.   The small party crept close to where one of the species was carolling when Anna stood on a stick, which broke.   Also broken (off) was the lyrebird’s song, not to be heard again    Messiaen was angry, as you might have expected.  But then, what sort of song-collector goes into the bush accompanied by a retinue that includes a journalist and photographer?

As ever, the music is what matters and the Sellars+Fujimura duet gives a fine airing of the Fantaisie and Benjamin’s self-possessed Sonata.  If you are left, like I am, wondering about the Kurtag brevities and their place in this Messiaen-infused collation, you can simply enjoy them for their own sakes, admiring the control and aplomb with which they are delivered.

IN RECITAL

James Brawn

MSR Classics MS1501

Taking a pause from his labours in recording the complete Beethoven piano sonatas , Brawn produced this album that holds the makings of what could have been an old-fashioned recital program, complete with inbuilt encores.   The most substantial work is a regular these days, as well as a favourite of pianists in previous generations: Mussorgsky’s Pictures at an Exhibition.  Some steps down in terms of stamina comes the Bach/Busoni Chaconne transcription, partnered in flamboyance with Liszt’s Mephisto Waltz No. 1.  Less taxing material technically comes in the Liszt Consolation No. 3 in D flat, Rachmaninov’s B minor Prelude, while the first of Bach’s Well-Tempered Clavier Preludes brings up the rear, whimsically plain-speaking after a welter of barnstorming virtuosity.

Both the smaller Liszt piece and the Bach prelude would be familiar to most pianists, although it takes a fair deal of work to get them sounding as uncluttered as Brawn makes them.   In its one-note-at-a-time progress, the C Major prelude asks for an even pace and a regularity of delivery that also avoids the automatic.  There are no absolutes in pedal use or using the initial notes of each bar as harmonic foci and the performance here is mobile and dutiful.   The Liszt nocturne gives a fine instance of evenly applied left-hand support, letting the melody float on its path unchallenged; perhaps the performer allows himself a fair liberality with pauses before pivotal bar-lines, but the outcome makes as much sense as possible of this simple effusion.

Moving up the degree of difficulty, Brawn creates an imaginative creature in the Rachmaninov piece, revealing the piece’s dark surges of energy carefully, not breaking the thread for effects in those central pages where the massive double-handed four-part chords compete for attention with an elephantine melodic movement.   In fact, judging by this one sample, the performer could have presented a few more from this Op. 32 set to excellent effect; he shows a gift of perceptiveness in unifying the composer’s grinding keyboard mastery with that inescapable granitic melancholy.

Busoni’s transcription and Liszt’s waltz offer a stark contrast in technical responsiveness. Both the products of incomparable pianists, the pieces are opposed in emotional character and underlying force; Busoni’s treatment of the original partita’s unaccompanied violin line is massive over-kill, while Liszt spends much of his time avoiding a waltz metre, even a waltz bar-line as he jumps between fine-spun filigree and pounding martellato passages.

Brawn impresses in the Chaconne with his ease at negotiating inbuilt problems like Busoni’s left-hand chords that stretch the hand to more than discomfort.  Further in, he handles both rapid octaves and sixths passages with controlled rapidity while observing the arranger’s late-Romantic dynamic contrasts.   One of the variations in my edition went AWOL – just before the con fuoco animato direction – but you get swept up in Brawn’s note-avalanche before you first notice.   On the switch to D Major, Brawn succeeds markedly in living up to the quasi Tromboni direction, then contrives to keep the work moving in the fifth of the major-key variants by skillfully arpeggiating the left-hand chords.   Unlike other pianists, Brawn refrains from treating the work in large-scale blocks, although his manipulation of the last two variants before D minor returns is a powerful percussive onslaught of semiquaver alternations between the hands.  The triplets come earlier in Brawn’s closing pages than in my score but he completes the  work with persuasive grit – which is what you need to get through its digital and aural vehemence.

Liszt’s showpiece demands crispness at the outset and this player has its measure with finely clipped articulation before the main melody hits the ground and the whirlwind – with breaks – takes off.   Those scurrying arpeggios and scalar runs across the top of the instrument show a suitable agility, and the sudden shifts in tonality and pace make their points rapidly before Brawn moves us on.   Still, he is not afraid to pull everything back 18 bars before the final Presto – an affecting passage of uneasy calm.  Yes, you can find a few smudges where the action is middle-keyboard, but what do you expect?  The rapidity of response that Liszt asks for  is unnervingly difficult; to get the notes right is a mighty achievement.

Still, after this reading I was left wondering about how closely Brawn was miked at the Potton Hall recording studio; given a more ample reverberation, this work in particular might have gained in aural presence   –   a more resonant envelope, a bit of echo to give its brittle superstructure some greater spatial ambience.

Mussorgsky’s suite is a marvel in live performance, in part for the sadistic pleasure an observer gets watching its execution,  the sheer effort of working through its pages.  But it has attracted pianists galore to record it; multiple times for Ashkenazy, Horowitz and Richter, among others.   Brawn’s version is straightforward, without any re-shaping or distortions, even though the original has scope for dynamic adventurousness.   As with previous recordings by this artist, you notice some elements that have not struck you before, like the crotchet in the left hand at the start of bar 60 in Gnomus when all you’ve heard before is the expected minim.  The second Promenade gave an addition to the composer’s gallery – a study in contemplation as the gallery-visitor moves along, illustrated with telling restraint by this page of delicatezza playing.

Keeping to the letter of the law, Brawn ensured that the dotted quaver-semiquaver-quaver pattern in The Old Castle stayed just that, not a slovenly triplet. In the Tuileries pages, he made herculean efforts to keep the treble semiquaver staccato runs detached.  Bydlo began as it should – loud;  nothing as trite as having this big wagon/cart slowly coming into view, then fading to incorporeality over the last bars.  The Unhatched Chickens Ballet came over with fleetness of hand, notable for the accelerando at the end of the first page (and at each of its reappearances).

A similar energizing animated the conclusion to the Limoges Market segment, Brawn making sure of his right-hand chords rather than blurring the bolt into the next picture, Catacombs, which has me still wondering how he achieved the massive left-hand stretch at bar 21.   Kiev’s Great Gate impressed for the slow pace adopted during the last 13 bars – the peroration after the bells and whistles have had their time in the sun.  Even so, this conclusion had some of its thunder stolen by the crotchet triplets section that follows the second chant interlude, here rising to a sonorously impressive clangour during Mussorgsky’s extended bell imitations.

This great example of musical pictorialism takes pride of place in the CD and Brawn presents an involving  reading of its familiar pages, untrammelled by distractions or superficiality.   Listeners would also enjoy the weighty power of Busoni’s take on Bach, as well as a glittering version of Liszt’s diabolic dance.

CHINA WIND

Robert Schubert

Move Records MD 3351

This CD is a testament to the friendship between clarinet master Robert Schubert and composer Julian Yu, as well as an illustration of the encouragement that one musician gives to another to broaden a particular instrument’s repertoire.   The recording sessions involved range from 2000 to 2012 and employ the talents of the Victorian College of the Arts Strings under Marco van Pagee and a collection of the soloist’s Melbourne University colleagues and Melbourne Symphony Orchestra peers past and present – flute Derek Jones, violins Isin Cakmakcioglu, Lorraine Hook and Deborah Goodall, violas Danielle Arcaro and Gabrielle Halloran, cellists Rachel Atkinson and Virginia Kable  –  as well as his wife, Akemi, on piano.

The five scores performed here are not the only ones by Yu that employ clarinet; just those where that instrument is the dominant voice.  The earliest, Sol Do La Re for clarinet and string trio, dates from 1985; Atanos, eleven years later, is written for flute, clarinet and string trio; The Lamentations of Micius for clarinet quintet comes from 1998; a 2000 triptych based on poems by the emperor Li Yu, Silent and Alone, asks for clarinet, piano and string quartet; and the latest music, from 2002, is the Concerto on Chinese Themes where the VCA players support Schubert.

Yu is a remarkably able writer and arranger, his professional equipment ever prepared for the task, whether it be original composition or arranging other composers – and here his activity is more expansive than I’d thought: Tchaikovsky, Palchelbel, Saint-Saens, Holst, Glinka, Janacek, Ligeti and Berg – or writing ‘fusions’ with masters like Mozart, Biber, Beethoven and Mussorgsky.  His activity level is high, as is his facility, which is a very apparent quality on this disc.

The most recently written music, the concerto, sounds the most traditional.   In the classic three-movement format, it is constricted by its melodic material, the tunes it uses not remarkable in shape.   The work begins with a slow introduction foregrounding the soloist who occasionally concludes a phrase with that ‘falling’ break you can hear on Chinese folk-music recordings.   The work changes pace to a fast allegro with lots of action for both clarinet and strings, the effect being mainly that of ‘busy’ music.  In the middle slower movement, it seems that one tune only serves the writer’s purpose and the impression is calm and placid, if reminiscent of a travelogue sound-track.   The finale is, of course, rapid and packed with twittering and trilling, the texture relieved by a segment involving woodblocks.   But Yu treats his basic material in a surprisingly orthodox manner, with very little here to ruffle any anti-modernist feathers.   It’s a pleasant enough entity, a fine vehicle for Schubert’s voluble C instrument, but very concerned to give the Chinese folk-tunes a plain and non-challenging setting.

The philosopher Micius (Mozi) grieved apparently about the  way silk was adulterated by being coloured, marring its original pristine state – just as man is ruined by increasing contact with a corrupting world.   Yu imitates the ch’in (zither) with plenty of initial pizzicati for Cakmakcioglu, Goodall, Arcaro and Atkinson before the texture alters to a more communal mesh where the wind player’s long notes are mirrored by the strings, although the emotional atmospheric changes are more dependent on the quartet than the clarinet at the score’s central point.   Yu’s suggestions of grieving oscillate; you have moments of sedate resignation, then energetic dissatisfaction, even menace and, under all, the restlessness of those pizzicati that seem determined to disturb the despair of Micius.   Here, Yu’s vocabulary is emphatically contemporary, loaded with disjunct leaps and juxtapositions.   Still, The Lamentation of Micius is an odd choice of subject, especially as the philosopher himself denounced music as a wasteful activity.

Atanos brings Jones’ flute into play straight away with Cakmakcioglu or Goodall (both are credited in the CD booklet), Arcaro and Atkinson joining to move this brisk jeu d’esprit forward.   A small group of motives are sprayed lavishly across the ensemble’s sound and range spectrum but the composer is principally concerned with using ornamentation to inform his country’s melodic lines, not simply transpose a tune holus-bolus into a Western chamber-music or harmonic garb.   In this piece, you can soon discern his use of scraps of phrases over and over, his texture pointillist and rapid-fire with plenty of doubling for the two wind instruments.   But whether the music is rapid or meditatively paced, its character is optimistic, quick-witted and content, the final pages an object lesson in economy of material, vaulting from near-stasis to a happy and communal rush of blood.

Using a tone-row, Sol Do La Re opens with those notes on Atkinson’s cello before Arcaro, Schubert and Cakmakcioglu join in the expansively argued fugal-type texture.  Written as an exercise while Yu was studying in Japan, the piece is a fine contrast with its predecessor on this CD: measured in pace, sticking to the same rather heavy rhythm, packed with references to technical devices, this almost abnegates personality for a  kind of academic gravity that interests for the manner in which it suggests tonality by its row’s disposition and the trend to concordance that runs throughout its brief length.

The Silent and Alone pieces are brief atmospheric vignettes with Schubert taking the vocal line that featured in the original version of this work.   He is supported by Akemi’s piano standing in for the first version’s harp   – Hook, Goodall, Halloran and Kable a quartet representing the chamber orchestra that Yu wrote for in the first place.   Since We Parted is a brief poem that centres on a melancholy longing for home; in this vision, the speaker is unhappy, but resigned while the strings suggest his inner urge to be on the move back with an impotent repetitive rhythm.

The title poem, probably the most famous of the emperor’s surviving pieces, poses the solitary speaker on an isolated tower beneath the moon, finding a self-reflection in a courtyard tree as the pang of parting strikes his consciousness with unexpected force. The piano sets out a haunting 8-note ascending figure over which the clarinet softly broods, interweaving with the strings to establish a soft mood of detached despair; only a brief burst of energy disturbs the music’s even flow to end almost as it began.

Lingering Thoughts puts the poet in a landscape fringed by mountains, vast sky and misty water where he is embroiled in the surroundings by his thoughts.  The seasons change but the expected traveller doesn’t return and the poet is left with moon and wind to populate his solitariness.   Here again, there is a surge of life before a voiceless conclusion.  The music throughout each of these pieces is reflective of European art song, even an impressionist-style scene-painting, but the colour is not daubed on in the Debussy Pagodes manner; the Chinese element stays recessed – present, but not blatant.  And the CD as a whole serves not just as a monument to Yu’s writing for clarinet as solo but also as an expertly accomplished exhibition of the composer’s range of abilities, in particular the charm of his lyrical line and the jaunty expertise of his instrumentation.

A BEETHOVEN ODYSSEY VOLUME 2

James Brawn

MSR Classics MS 1466

In this second instalment of Brawn’s review of the complete Beethoven piano sonatas, the performer works through three of the very well-known masterpieces: the Pathetique No 8 in C minor, the Moonlight No 14 in C sharp minor, and the Waldstein No. 21 in C Major.  Each of these is familiar to pianists, both capable and the vaultingly ambitious, necessary obstacles on the path to self-recognition and all capable of fostering self-delusion.   As well, Brawn includes the two ‘easy’ catalogue-listed preludes to the Waldstein, although both Sonatas 19 and 20 were written almost a decade previously than their position suggests, closer in time to the Pathetique and atypically lean in content and texture.

It’s sort of like putting all the populist eggs in one basket and thus it makes the CD an attractive buying proposition.   Fortunately, the finished product is well worth attention for its own sake, beginning with a clean-limbed reading of the C minor work.   As the first disc in this series demonstrated, Brawn has a canny eye for details that others neglect or ignore, like the crescendo five bars into the first movement’s Allegro which comes at the right place rather than featuring in the ascending chord sequence that precedes it.  Throughout these pages   –   and the rest of the work, for that matter  –   Brawn distinguishes himself from many another performer by playing what’s written, giving full courtesy to Beethoven and his listeners.   He keeps to his tempi, maintains a clear texture, gives notes their right length, builds and releases tension with subtlety, and preserves the work’s stark directness of expression.   For once, the sudden Grave bars are delivered with as much sombre weight as they deserve.

Like the first movement, the Adagio cantabile comes across with a balanced deliberation, its progress interspersed with subtle semi-pauses denoting a sectional  change or something as simple as an imminent reprise.   Five bars from the end, for the first time ever, I heard a splendidly achieved crescendo/decrescendo that had never struck me before.   No murky blowsiness in the light-filled Rondo.   Mozart was only dead 7/8 years before and his influence is still pervasive; certainly, Beethoven’s gloom and thunder is approaching but, at this stage, not full-blown.   Here again come details that never struck you previously, like the cut back to piano at bar 182; it’s probably there on many other versions but this time its appearance is striking.    Brawn repeatedly displays an awareness of colour differentiation, as in the change from the semiquaver patterns of bars 107-112 to the immediately-following triplets: the landscape changes abruptly even though the underpinning urgent tension remains constant.

Too much has been inferred about the C sharp minor sonata’s history/background/ positioning in the composer’s love-life, but Brawn communicates from the first the dark, looming passion that informs the work.   He takes the direction delicatissimamente as a prime directive for the opening Adagio which remains on the move, sticking to an orthodox path although a hesitation with the broken 7th chord at bars 35-37 added a human touch to this dour nocturne.   The Allegretto was paced more slowly than other pianists treat it, which is usually as an aimless burst of bucolic sunshine.   In this handling, the page impresses as a more valid sequel to the liquid first movement; here there is doubt, regret, an autumnal calm as the composer pauses before the sonata’s scorching finale.

Brawn tries very hard and almost completely succeeds in making a sforzando on only the first of the repeated chords that finish off each arpeggio run-up in the Presto‘s first theme; it’s a remarkable effect, leaving you dangling.  Yes, other players observe the same dynamic direction but here the dent in your expectations is strikingly sharp.   Some excellent pianism appears with an impressive recovery rate in the leaps that pepper bars 47 to 56, and the demisemiquaver clusters from bars 163 to 165 reverberate like side-drum flourishes.   In all, the player offers a no-nonsense version of this restless Rondo, too often treated with that latitude afforded to Chopin’s final Op. 10 etude.

When the track for Sonata No. 19 began, it suddenly hit me that I’ve never heard this work live.  It is easy to churn out the notes, which may make it unattractive to recitalists,  but the atmospheric vein it explores presents interpretative problems.   Brawn invests it with a dignity that brings to the work’s few pages a kind of substantiality.   He gives its phrases every consideration, avoids any indication of hurrying, but impresses on his audience the movement’s small-framed restraint.   A delight from start to finish, the following Rondo/Allegro is an ignored treasure, packed with finesse; for example, the difference in how the player follows the same expression markings in close succession  –  at bars 120-121 and bars 122-3.

Sonata No. 20 is an open-slather field, with only two definite expression directions in its second movement; you can let yourself go, your realization tempered chiefly by the work’s sunny gentility.   Brawn keeps his attack rational and moderately dynamic; he presents an interesting outline, giving the left hand equal billing rather than falling in love with the optimistic upper melodic ripples.    I greatly appreciated his crispness in the Minuet, specifically his delivery of the over-riding rhythmic figure of dotted quaver-semiquaver- crotchet or minim: the simplest of motifs but once heard, never forgotten   This movement’s three pages enjoy a snappy delivery, a modestly exuberant skip in the Minuet itself well balanced by the lusty gusto of the C Major Trio.   It all makes for a performing style of delicacy without affectation.

Brawn ends his disc with the C Major Waldstein, a cow of a work written in the simplest of keys but loaded with pitfalls.  This version copes with pretty much every handicap that Beethoven loads on, the pace blistering from the rustling repeated bass chords that kick off the journey.   During the second theme’s announcement, Brawn concerns himself with the alto part at bar 38, the line carried on by the tenor at bars 47-48; it’s there to be played but a good many pianists concern themselves mainly with the decorative soprano triplets only.   Still, this executant knows that the only game in town when triplets take over the development is the harmonic changes and he powers through them to achieve maximum effect from the juxtapositions.   Listen to the relentless flying build-up of excitement (through a simple ascending scale in the bass) between bars 268-276 and you’ll hear as gripping a reading of this difficult passage-of-play as you could want.

The second movement Introduzione brings an abrupt change  –  Adagio molto  –  and Brawn delivers that exactly, descending gracefully from the page’s insistent dynamic highpoint to a near-mute bar 26 before gliding into the Rondo tour de force.   For the most part, he follows those notorious sustaining-pedal directions, an oddity I fail to fathom every time I hear this movement.   Moreover, Brawn does excellent, sometimes brilliant work with other obstacles  –  like the two-hand contrary motion triplets that go on and on from bar 352 to 377; later, the glissandi featured in bars 465 and 474 come across with admirable smoothness.    But the movement, despite its few moments of relief, is a slog; most of the interpolated episodes approach the bloody-minded and the trill work required adds a Pelion to Beethoven’s already oppressive Ossa.

Brawn gives a bracing account of this challenging score, not letting himself off by taking the easy road with jog-trot speeds, convenient easing-up at danger points, or slackening the tension with mid-sentence pauses.    There’s worse to come with the Les Adieux, No 28 in A, the Hammerklavier  .  .  .  in fact, all of the last five sonatas are packed with enough unnerving material to deter most of us.    But, so far with Brawn, the signs are more than promising.

MUSIC FOR TRUMPET AND THE KING OF INSTRUMENTS

Bruno Siketa and Rhys Boak

Move Records MD 3379

Another addition to the impressive number of collaborative recordings on the Move label, this trumpet-and-organ effort offers a wide mix, ranging from Bach without frills to arrangements that are packed with incident.   The playing involves two organs: the Hill/Fincham instrument in St. Michael’s Uniting Church on Collins Street where Boak is the resident performer, and one in ‘Collingwood Castle’ where the Radixon Group has its Islington Street headquarters and which, despite assiduous searching, retains its mysteries as a privately-owned construct.

The Collingwood organ is used for duets exclusively while the artists also perform four works at the city church, which is where Boak chose to record his solos.   An early indication of the hybrid nature of the material on offer comes in the first track, an arrangement by both musicians of the Albinoni Adagio in G minor, now known to have been written by Remo Giazotto – not the first ghostwriter to take a leaf out of the Kreisler creative-abnegation handbook.    As expected with this slow-moving dirge, there are a few notes where tuning is not spot-on.   Less importantly, you can’t avoid feeling that the chord-supported cadenza-like passages for the trumpet  come straight from a spaghetti western – the spirit of Morricone putting in an unanticipated appearance.

Telemann’s Heroic Marches, La Generosite and La Grace, fare better, although in the first Siketa’s low Gs close to the start are questionable; the second piece’s slow D Major stateliness works much better for both players as a whole.

Boak’s first solo is Bach’s Toccata and Fugue in D minor, which is now ascribed to one of the composer’s students or friends; exactly which one is the problem.    This reading is unexceptional, with no Ton Koopman-style surprises in ornamentation or registration; only one unexpected pause for what could be a change of manual in mid-fugue disrupts the regular rhythmic underpinning of the work’s second part up to the ducks-and-drakes games at the Recitativo.   Later in the CD, the Little Fugue in G minor is handled with similar directness of utterance in the warm St. Michael’s acoustic.   During Edwin Lemare‘s transcription of the Pilgrims’ Chorus from Wagner’s Tannhauser, Boak shows a controlled flamboyance, the work’s inexorable progress handled with musicianship so that the decorative violin patterns that accompany the chorale in its stentorian climactic form remain in their place.   Guilmant‘s 1861 March on a theme by Handel is treated sensibly as a long crescendo, starting off with a theme outline in unusually reserved manner, gaining headway in the middle fugue and exerting plenty of sonorous muscle in the final grandiose pages.

Siketa gives to Alan Hovhaness‘s A Prayer f St. Gregory a calm delineation, which is the best approach possible with a work that is meant to depict a holy man’s spiritual and physical crisis expressed in semi-modal language that takes the listener nowhere.   Piazzolla’s Ave Maria was written for a film version of Pirandello’s Enrico IV, originally scored for oboe and piano; Siketa produces an attractive line but the piece itself is nondescript, a meander that indicates a mental break between its devotional re-naming and its original purpose.

The Romance from Shostakovich’s score to Aleksandr Fajntsimmer’s film The Gadfly sees the players in Collingwood and the tuning for the piece’s first pages is still not quite right, although matters improve by the reprise.   Rachmaninov’s Vocalise, another favourite Russian lollipop, enjoys more success and the arrangement by Boak, moving down a semitone from the original C sharp, uses the organ to good effect, although its dynamic pays over-deferential courtesy to the brass melody line which remains very prominent. The pair end their suburban bracket with the Ave Maria attributed to Caccini (how?) but composed by Vladimir Vavilov; as in every other version you hear of this piece, the executants never come close to being challenged.

The final trumpet+organ works are unabashed showpieces.  Jean-Baptiste Arban‘s Theme et variations sur ‘Norma’ holds some preparatory and fill-in work for the accompanist but its only interest is the trumpet’s virtuosity.   Siketa begins with a straightforward outline of Bellini’s Casta diva aria  –  well, the first part of it  –  complete with a cadenza at the end. The first variation is a bouncy march distinctive for a bit of quick action at its conclusion. Variation 2 continues in the same metre but with continuous semiquavers; not jerking the player around but testing his evenness of enunciation.   Matters ratchet up in Variation 3 where the action moves to triplets – really sextuplets – and the player is hard pressed; Siketa manages this very competently – I heard only one near-dropped note at bar 100.   A piu lento is the deceptive lead-in to the last section which features a gradual acceleration leading to a brilliantly definite conclusion.   In the excitement, the synchronicity between the players put Siketa under stress; at points like bar 135 where he had to draw breath, there was a danger of his being left behind by his inexorable escort in the race to the piece’s final post.

The other showpiece is better known as a violin encore: Monti’s Csardas; this appears to be the work’s first re-positioning for trumpet and organ.   It’s a brave effort but perhaps the unspoken request to ignore the original is impractical.   Triple- and double-stops are impossible to accomplish, as is the Meno quasi lento segment in harmonics which is taken over by Boak; any spicy acciacaturas are too difficult to negotiate in this context.   Still, the interpretation goes some way to catching the original’s faux-Gypsy spirit and there are precious few flaws, the most notable a missed note eight bars before the final A tempo/piu presto gallop.

I think that the motive underpinning this recording is more entertainment value than repertoire expansion, although it does accomplish that end with six of the tracks being arrangements by Boak.   The content jumps around – from familiar Bach and Telemann to Hovhaness of 1946 and a 1984 piece by Piazzolla, the most modern of the 14 works presented.    It will interest trumpeters, I suspect, and admirers of both Melbourne musicians involved  –  and those with a taste for that noble, vital sound-world so desired by wedding organists who have to make do with their trumpet stops: a poor substitute for the real thing, as this CD demonstrates.